It’s the toughest test in golf. Who will leave the Olympic Club as the 2012 United States Open champion on Sunday afternoon? Photo courtesy The Observer.
It’s finally here.
No. It’s not the end of the world as the Mayans predicted, but instead it’s the return of the United States Open championship to famed Olympic Club in San Francisco.
Designed by Sam Whiting and Willie Watson back in the 1920s, Olympic Club has previously hosted eight USGA championships, including four US Opens (1955, 1966, 1987, 1998), three US Amateurs (1958, 1981, 2007) and the 2004 US Junior. In those four US Opens, the winning score to par has been -3, -2, E and +7. Thus, the 156 players who will duke it out at Olympic Club for the 2012 US Open will face what has come to be known as the toughest test in golf on a track not known for a multitude of low scores.
So, who is expected to be there on Sunday with a chance to hoist the US Open trophy, and will they actually be there with a major championship on the line?
Defending champion Rory McIlroy comes to Olympic Club fresh off a T-7th finish at last week’s FedEx St. Jude Classic. Going off just that finish alone it would appear that McIlroy is in fine form ahead of his title defense. That, however, is misleading. In his three starts prior to Memphis, the 23-year-old Northern Irishman missed three consecutive cuts worldwide (Players Championship, BMW PGA Championship, Memorial Tournament), before righting the ship a little bit. Despite his recent MCs, McIlroy has confidence because he is the defending champion and he has had other high finishes in majors. Throw in a win, three runner-up finishes and two other top-5 finishes across the globe this season, and McIlroy has played very well in 2012. The biggest knock, however, is that he has recently struggled hitting the fairways, and at the US Open that means many missed greens and a slew of bogeys. Oh, and the last man to win consecutive US Opens was Curtis Strange in 1988 and 1989. I say McIlroy posts a top-20 finish, but isn’t a threat on the weekend.
Three-time US Open Tiger Woods is always a strong favourite at whatever tournament he shows up at, and that favouritism is amped up at major championships. Yes, he’s the current betting favourite, and at 8/1 odds is worth throwing a few dollars bills on, especially since he arrives at Olympic Club after winning his last start at the Memorial Tournament. But Woods has been very up-and-down with his results this season. His T-2nd at the Honda Classic was followed by a WD the following week at Doral. Then after winning in his next start at Bay Hill expectations were high that he’d don a fifth green jacket at the Masters (I actually picked him to win), but he finished T-40th. A missed cut in his next start at the Wells Fargo Championship was followed by another ordinary T-40th at The Players Championship before he won at Jack’s place. And Woods, unlike a number of the great young players in the world, has US Open experience at Olympic Club. He finished T-18th at the 1998 edition. Nonetheless, even though Woods (surprisingly) ranks 1st in total driving on the PGA Tour this season, lately in majors he has struggled finding fairways and I think that will be his demise this week. The world’s no. 4 ranked player should be a factor come Saturday and Sunday, but I don’t see him holding the 54-hole lead which translates into Woods not finishing with the 72-hold lead. Woods nets a top-10 finish this week.
The other big American favourite is five-time US Open runner-up Phil Mickelson. Lefty’s Open record is noteworthy on account of those five second place finishes in this championship (1999, 2002, 2004, 2006, 2009). The one in 2006, however, still resonates with those who doubt Mickelson will ever win the championship he so very much desires to capture. The simple version of that disappointing Sunday was that Mickelson held a one-shot lead standing on the 72nd tee before blocking his tee shot way left, chopping his way up to the green, finishing with a disastrous double-bogey and gift-wrapping the US Open trophy for Geoff Ogilvy. But I’m a Mickelson guy. Always have been. Always will be. And I believe Lefty has a chance to exercise those demons this week, and if not this week, then at future US Opens. His recent WD at the Memorial Tournament isn’t discouraging, nor is the fact that he let a chance to win his fourth green jacket slip away from him in April with a triple-bogey at the par-3 4th hole in the final round. Mickelson makes magic, and his T-10th finish at the 1998 US Open at Olympic Club, despite the numerous changes to the golf course, bodes well for another big US Open week for him. A top-5 finish for Lefty is a certainty this week.
He is considered by many members of the media and golf fans to be the best player in the world without a major championship victory, but world no. 1 Luke Donald, has a great opportunity to get that monkey off his back this week at Olympic Club. Donald has finished 3rd, 6th, 1st and 12th in his last four starts worldwide. That win came at the European Tour’s flagship event, the BMW PGA Championship, which he successfully defended. He also captured the Transitions Championship back in March. But Donald, after struggling early in the 2012 season, has found his game and seems to be running on all cylinders ahead of the year’s second major. But pedigree in US Opens has to count for something. In eight previous starts, the Englishman’s best finish came back in 2006 at Winged Foot where he finished T-12th. Clearly, Donald is due to at least snag his first top-10 finish at a US Open, but I don’t think this is the week and that major drought will be prolong itself at least until next month’s Open Championship at Royal Lytham and St Annes. Donald finishes outside the top-25 in his first trip to Olympic Club.
The two men in this week’s field who are coming off wins this past weekend are steady-as-he-goes Lee Westwood and long-bombing Dustin Johnson. Let’s start with Westwood. He won the Nordea Masters in Sweden on Saturday for his first worldwide win of the season, and has been the best player without a win in a major since the 2008 US Open at Torrey Pines. Since finishing 3rd place, one shot out of the Woods-Rocco Mediate playoff, at Torrey Pines, Westwood has collected six other top-3 finishes in majors (2009 PGA and Open Championships, 2010 Masters and Open Championship, 2011 US Open, 2012 Masters). Needless to say, Westwood is overdue to capture that maiden major championship title. Could this be his week? As for Johnson, his win last week at Memphis was somewhat unexpected in that he was making just his second PGA Tour start after two months off nursing a back injury. But a win is a win, and for a world class player like Johnson who just needs some reps, its got to feel good and give him a ton of confidence heading back to a championship he led by three shots after 54 holes before imploding with a final round 82 to finish T-8th. That came back in 2010 at Pebble Beach, which was won by Graeme McDowell. Johnson didn’t play at Augusta National back in April because of his back injury, so he ought to be eager to be back in a major championship field for the first time since a MC at last year’s PGA Championship. I think Johnson plays okay at Olympic Club, but doesn’t net better than a top-30. As for Westwood, seven top-3 finishes in the last 16 majors counts for a lot, and I see Westy adding another top-3 this week.
Other big-name players, including Masters champion Bubba Watson, Players Champion Matt Kuchar, Wells Fargo Champion Rickie Fowler, Byron Nelson Classic champion Zach Johnson and two-time 2012 PGA tour winners Jason Dufner and Hunter Mahan all have the game to tame Olympic Club. But will any or all of them be in the fray Sunday afternoon? Out of these six players, I would peg Kuchar as the best of the lot to be a factor on Sunday. Not only because he recently won the biggest title of his career, but because he also recently truly contended in a major for the first time, a T-3rd finish at the Masters, to go along with his T-6th finish at the 2010 US Open. Factor in that Kuchar contended in the 1998 US Open, where he sat T-4th after 36 holes en route to a T-14th finish and low amateur honours, and I see Kuchar finishing in the top-10 this week. As for the other five guys, only Watson and Mahan have posted top-10s (one each) at the US Open, so their pedigree in this championship doesn’t blow you away. But I could definitely see Dufner as a dark horse this week.
What do I think will play out this week?
First of all, the golf course is going to play difficult firm and fast, and even more so as the week progresses because no rain is expected to fall during the course of the championship. Second of all, it’s the US Open, so the player that winds up holding the trophy after surviving both the other 155 competitors and the beast of a golf course will have to be “in the zone” mentally all week. Thirdly, I think the winning score will be over par, +1 to be precise. Yes, I know the only over par score to win the US Open in the past 33 years was Geoff Ogilvy’s +5 total in 2006, but I think over par wins this US Open. Fourthly, I love the par-5, par-5, short par-4 finish that will play out. In 1998, the 17th hole, then a par-4, was the hardest hole on the course all week, but this week the 17th hole will play as a reachable par-5 that figures to see a fair number of eagles and a boatload of birdies. Love it, and props to Mike Davis and the USGA for setting up the course with such an exciting finishing stretch. Fifthly, I can’t wait to see how 14-year-old Andy Zhang plays as it relates to the best golfers in the world. Lastly, Lee Westwood will join the likes of Jack Fleck, Billy Casper, Scott Simpson and Lee Janzen as US Opens at Olympic Club.
Predictions:
Winner: Lee Westwood
Runner-up: Matt Kuchar
Dark Horse: Davis Love III
Surprise Good: Scott Langley
Surprise Bad: Bubba Watson
Low Amateur: Patrick Cantlay